Comparing eBay and Amazon Seller Fees: Which Platform Is Worth It?

Choosing the right eCommerce platform is one of the most crucial decisions you’ll make as an online seller. With two of the biggest players—eBay and Amazon—dominating the space, it’s important to determine which platform offers the best value for your business.

In this article, we’ll break down the seller fees on both platforms and help you decide which marketplace can deliver the most bang for your buck.

Seller Fees Breakdown: eBay vs. Amazon

Selling online isn’t free. Both eBay and Amazon come with their fee structures, and understanding these costs is vital to maintaining healthy profit margins. Here’s what you need to know about each platform’s fees.

eBay Seller Fees: What to Expect

eBay offers sellers flexibility but at a cost. Here’s a clear breakdown of eBay’s key fees:

1. Insertion Fee
   eBay provides 250 free listings per month, but after that, you’ll be charged an insertion fee of $0.35 per listing.
2. Final Value Fee
   When an item sells, eBay charges a final value fee, typically between 0.5% to 15% of the total sale, depending on the product category.
3. Promoted Listings
   eBay’s Promoted Listings help boost your product’s visibility, but you’re charged only when a sale results from a promoted listing. Rates typically range between 2% and 100%, depending on competition.
4. Store Subscription Fee
   If you’re a frequent seller, an eBay store subscription could save you money. Here’s what the monthly fees look like:
   • Starter Store: $4.95
   • Basic Store: $21.95
   • Premium Store: $59.95
   • Anchor Store: $299.95
   • Enterprise Store: $2,999.95
5. International Fees
   If you sell to buyers outside your home country, expect international fees between 1% and 1.70% based on the region.

Amazon Seller Fees: A Closer Look

Amazon’s fee structure is quite different and generally higher. Here’s a breakdown:

1. Subscription Fees
   Unlike eBay, Amazon doesn’t charge per listing. Instead, you choose between an Individual Plan ($0.99 per sale) or a Professional Plan ($39.99 per month).
2. Referral Fees
   Amazon charges a referral fee per sale, ranging from 8% to 15%, depending on the category. This is typically higher than eBay’s final value fee.
3. Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) Fees
   If you choose FBA, where Amazon handles storage, shipping, and customer service, fees are based on the size and weight of your items. The service offers perks like Prime eligibility and customer support.
4. Storage Fees
   FBA sellers also pay storage fees, calculated by cubic footage and season. Expect higher charges during peak months (October to December).

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Between eBay and Amazon

Beyond fees, other factors impact your decision on which platform to sell on.

1. Customer Reach

Amazon boasts a much larger customer base, with over 300 million active users compared to eBay’s 138 million. If reaching a wider audience is your goal, Amazon is a stronger option.

2. Sales Volume

In 2022, Amazon generated a staggering $514 billion in sales, while eBay came in at $9.79 billion. If you’re looking to scale quickly, Amazon’s high-volume marketplace could be advantageous.

3. Competition

Competition on Amazon can be fierce, as it attracts many established brands. eBay, on the other hand, is known for its niche markets and appeals to buyers seeking unique or second-hand items.

4. Product Promotion Options

Both platforms offer advertising tools, but Amazon Advertising provides more extensive options like Sponsored Products and Sponsored Displays. eBay’s Promoted Listings are simpler, but still effective for increasing product visibility.

Which Platform Offers Better Seller Protection?

Both platforms prioritize protecting buyers and sellers, but Amazon’s robust payment and return policies give it a slight edge. Amazon’s streamlined processes make it safer for sellers, particularly when it comes to managing returns and refunds.

Final Verdict: eBay or Amazon?

The choice between eBay and Amazon depends on your business goals and priorities. If you’re looking for greater flexibility and lower fees, eBay might be the ideal choice for your business needs. However, if you’re aiming for broader exposure, advanced selling tools, and larger sales potential, Amazon could be your ideal choice.

Selling on Amazon? Let Us Help You Maximize Your Success!

Are you ready to take the plunge into Amazon’s vast marketplace but unsure where to start? Pro Seller Marketing is here to guide you. From product listing optimization to account management, our expert team can help you navigate the complexities of selling on Amazon and maximize your profits.

Book a free consultation with us today and discover how we can elevate your Amazon business!